I really like first one. Lighting works. could be better. Since it's diffuse light , you have to be very pricese about the values. Push the right side little further. and be more precise about the brush stroke. They are still little messy. More variation for 2nd stage. You have enough thumbs. Burt more of the 2nd stage variations.
hey charles, sorry im getting bakc to you so late. so for the 1st one, is there any reference of what I should go for in regards to the lighting.